GTO 2022 Peer Review

2020 Project Peer Review - U.S. Department of Energy Geothermal Technologies Office

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Geothermal Technologies Office (GTO) hosted its 2022 Peer Review in May 2022. During the peer review, 62 GTO-funded projects were presented by investigators and reviewed by external subject matter experts from industry, academia, and federal agencies.

To find information on past peer reviews, visit the GTO Peer Review webpage.

Research Areas and Structure
GTO’s Multi-Year Program Plan (MYPP) outlines a 5-year plan of activities GTO will pursue to support the growth and long-term contribution of geothermal energy to the U.S. electricity grid and American homes and buildings. The MYPP lays out six research areas that provide the foundation for GTO’s research activities. The 2022 Peer Review presentations are organized by these research areas:

  • Exploration and Characterization
  • Subsurface Accessibility
  • Resource Maximization
  • Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability
  • Data, Modeling, and Analysis

Check out the 2022 Peer Review Report here.

Agenda
The 2022 Peer Review took place on May 10, 12, 16, 18, 24, and 26. Timings are shown in both Pacific Daylight Time (PDT) and Eastern Daylight Time (EDT). 

Day 1: Tuesday, May 10, 2022

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)
    TitlePresenter
    7:30 / 10:30Welcome and Introduction GTO Leadership Team
     Break out to Virtual Room 1 or Virtual Room 2 

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 1

    GTO (Michael Weathers)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    INnovative Geothermal Exploration through Novel Investigations Of Undiscovered Systems (INGENIOUS)

    University of Nevada Reno (Bridget Ayling)

    Exploration and Characterization

    8:50 / 11:50

    BRIDGE (Basin & Range Investigations for Developing Geothermal Energy) to Hidden Systems

    SNL (Paul Schwering)

    Exploration and Characterization

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

      

    10:00 / 1:00

    Understanding a Stratigraphic Hydrothermal Resource – Geophysical Imaging at Steptoe Valley, Nevada

    SNL (Paul Schwering)

    Exploration and Characterization

    10:50 / 1:50

    Using Dark Fiber and Distributed Acoustic Sensing to Map and Monitor Geothermal
    Resources at the Basin Scale

    LBNL (Veronica Rodriguez)

    Exploration and Characterization

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

      

    11:50 / 2:50

    PFA Retrospective

    NREL (Ian Warren)

    Exploration and Characterization

    12:40 / 3:40

    Innovative Subsurface Learning and Hawaiian Exploration using Advanced Tomography (ISLAND HEAT)

    NREL (Ian Warren)

    Exploration and Characterization

    1:25 / 4:25

    Return to Main Room

      
  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 2

    GTO (Jeff Bowman)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Community Resilience Through Low-Temperature Geothermal Reservoir Thermal Energy Storage

    LBNL (Peter Nico)

    Resource Maximization

    8:50 / 11:50

    Dynamic Earth Energy Storage: Terawatt-Year, Grid-Scale Energy Storage using Planet Earth as a Thermal Battery (RTES)

    INL (Travis McLing)

    Resource Maximization

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Novel Heat Pump Integrated Underground Thermal Energy Storage for Shaping Electric Demand of Buildings

    ORNL (Xiaobing Liu)

    Resource Maximization

    10:50 / 1:50

    Advanced Techno-Economic Modeling for Geothermal Heat Pump Applications in Residential, Commercial, & Industrial Buildings

    ORNL (Xiaobing Liu)

    Resource Maximization

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Geothermal Operational Optimization with Machine Learning (GOOML)

    Upflow Limited (Paul Siratovich)

    Resource Maximization

    12:40 / 3:40

    TBD

    TBD

    TBD

    1:25 / 4:25

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    1:30 / 4:30

    Geothermal Coproduction at Blackburn Oil Field, Nevada

    Transitional Energy (Benjamin Burke)

    1:45 / 4:45

    Intelligent Repurposing of Hydrocarbon Wells System to Harness the Geothermal Potential of Oklahoma Sedimentary Basin

    University of Oklahoma (Saeed Salehi)

    2:00 / 5:00

    Zero-emission Power Generation from Oil and Gas Production Streams

    ICE Thermal Harvesting (Carrie Murtland)

Day 2: Thursday, May 12, 2022

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 1

    GTO (George Stutz)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Amplify EGS Near-Field Characterization Project

    LBNL (Michelle Robertson) 

    SNL (Jiann Su)

    Exploration & Characterization

    8:50 / 11:50

    GEOTHERMICA: DE-risking Exploration of geothermal Plays in magmatic Environments

    NREL (Amanda Kolker)

    Exploration & Characterization

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Cloud Fusion of Big Data and Multi-Physics Models using Machine Learning for Discovery, Exploration and Development of Hidden Geothermal Resources

    LANL (Maruti Mudunuru)

    Exploration & Characterization

    10:50 / 1:50

    Detecting and Characterizing Fracture Zones Using Convolutional Neural Network

    University of Houston (Yingcai Zheng)

    Exploration & Characterization

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Geothermal Anomaly Detection from Hyperspectral Images via Deep Learning

    Colorado School of Mines (Sebnem Duzgun)

    Exploration & Characterization

    12:40 / 3:40

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 2

    GTO (Arlene Anderson)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Impact Analysis of Heating Electrification in the U.S. Buildings with Geothermal Heat Pumps

    ORNL (Xiaobing Liu) 

    NREL (Jonathan Ho)

    Resource Maximization

    8:50 / 11:50

    Geothermal Deep Direct-Use Combined with Reservoir Thermal Energy Storage on the West Virginia University Campus-Morgantown, WV

    West Virginia University (Nagasree Garapati)

    Resource Maximization

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Ground-Truthing: Exploratory Borehole Characterization and Modeling to Verify and Expand Techno-Economic Evaluation of Earth Source Heat

    Cornell University (Steve Beyers)

    Resource Maximization

    10:50 / 1:50

    All Metal Zonal Isolation for Geothermal Reservoirs

    Welltec Inc (Yosafat Esquitin)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Geothermal in the Arctic - GTO at WGC Support

    NREL (Amanda Kolker)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    12:40 / 3:40

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    12:45 / 3:45

    Porous polymer to modify fracture permeability

    University of New Mexico (John Stormont)

    1:00 / 4:00

    Geothermal Heat Pump & Phase Change Material Super-Hybrid Systems

    Melink Corporation (Roshan Revankar)

Day 3: Monday, May 16, 2022

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 1

    GTO (Zach Frone)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Seismoelectric Effects for Geothermal Resources Assessment and Monitoring (SEE4GEO)

    LLNL (Christina Morency)

    Exploration & Characterization

    8:50 / 11:50

    Insightful Subsurface Characterizations and Predictions

    NREL (Koenraad Beckers)

    Exploration & Characterization

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Drilling Technologies Evaluation

    SNL (David Raymond)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    10:50 / 1:50

    Microhole Drilling – Application of Low Weight-on-Bit Technologies

    SNL (Jiann Su)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Targeted Energy Focusing to Induce Micro-Cracking for Reduced Cutting Energy and Increased Rate of Penetration

    Texas A&M (David Staack)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    12:40 / 3:40

    Toward Drilling the Perfect Geothermal Well: An International Research Coordination Network for Geothermal Drilling Optimization Supported by Deep Machine Learning and Cloud Based Data Aggregation

    Oregon State (Adam Schultz)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    1:25 / 4:25

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 2

    GTO (Angel Nieto)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    GEOTHERMICA: SPINE: Stress Profiling in EGS

    LBNL (Yves Guglielmi)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    8:50 / 11:50

    GEOTHERMICA: DEEP: Innovation for De-Risking Enhanced Geothermal Energy Projects

    LBNL (Nori Nakata)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    The EGS Collab SIGMA-V Project: Stimulation Investigations for Geothermal Modeling Analysis and Validation – Multiple National Laboratories

    LBNL (Tim Kneafsey)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    10:50 / 1:50

    Increasing Power Generation at the Patua Nevada Geothermal Field through Targeted and Adaptive EGS

    Patua Acquisition Company, LLC (Trenton Cladouhos)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Enhanced Geothermal System Concept Testing and Development at the Milford City, Utah FORGE Site

    University of Utah (Joseph Moore)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    12:40 / 3:40

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    1:30 / 4:30

    Advanced, Low-Cost Indoor Heat Exchanger for Geothermal Heat Pump Systems

    Mainstream Engineering Corporation (David Sykes)

    1:45 / 4:45

    Electrical and Thermal Energy Storage for Geothermal Power Plants

    Nrgtek Inc. (Subramanian Iyer)

    2:00 / 5:00

    Feasibility of Storing Heat in the Subsurface for Flexible Electricity Generation

    Projeo Corporation (Nicholas Malkewicz)

Day 4: Wednesday, May 18, 2022

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 1

    GTO (Alexandra Prisjatschew)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    GEOTHERMICA: TEST-CEM: Sustainable Geothermal Well Cements for Challenging Thermo-Mechanical Conditions

    BNL (Tatiana Pyatina)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    8:50 / 11:50

    Sustainable Well Cement for Geothermal, Thermal Recovery, and Carbon Storage Wells

    BNL (Tatiana Pyatina)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Advanced Insulating Lightweight Thermal Shock-Resistant Cement (TILTSRC) Suitable To Withstand Frequent Thermal Cycling

    BNL (Tatiana Pyatina)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    10:50 / 1:50

    Development of a Directional Cooling Induced Fracturing (DCIF) Technology for Near-Wellbore Stress Estimation in Geothermal Reservoirs

    RESPEC (Samuel Voegeli)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Changing the Ways Geothermal Wells Are Drilled: Physics-Based Drilling Parameter Selection, Workflow Implementation and Training in Order to Reduce Non-Productive Time and Increased ROP

    Texas A&M (Sam Noynaert)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    12:40 / 3:40

    Demonstration of Ceramicrete® as a Robust Geothermal Well Cement

    ANL (Oyelayo Ajayi)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    1:25 / 4:25

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 2

    GTO (Kevin Jones)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Machine Learning Approaches to Predicting Induced Seismicity and Imaging Geothermal Reservoir Properties

    Penn State University (Chris Marone)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    8:50 / 11:50

    Improved Lost Circulation Management for Geothermal Drilling

    LBNL (Pat Dobson)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Supercritical Systems

    LBNL (Eric Sonnenthal)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    10:50 / 1:50

    Collection of Microearthquake (MEQ) Data for Mitigating, Characterizing, and Understanding Induced Seismicity for Optimizing the Performance of EGS

    LBNL (Nori Nakata)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    WHOLESCALE — Water & Hole Observations Leverage Effective Stress Calculations and Lessen Expenses

    U. Madison Wisconsin (Kurt Feigl)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    12:40 / 3:40

    ZIPPER: Zonal isolation with plug and perf in enhanced reservoirs

    Fervo Energy Company (Jack Norbeck)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

     1:25 / 4:25

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    1:30 / 4:30

    Energy Storage Grand Challenge Benchmarking

    INL (Daniel Ginosar)

    1:45 / 4:45

    Comparative Analysis of Three Sequential Near-Field Well Stimulations at Three Operating Geothermal Fields in Nevada

    Ormat Nevada Inc (John Akerly)

    2:00 / 5:00

    Well Construction Working Group and Roadmapping

    ORNL (Yarom Polsky)

Day 5: Tuesday, May 24, 2022

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 1

    GTO (William Vandermeer)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Development of Advanced Bit Material To Increase ROP in Geothermal Drilling

    ANL (Oyelayo Ajayi)

     

    8:50 / 11:50

    Developing Advanced Lost Prevention Methods and Smart Wellbore Strengthening Materials for Geothermal Wells

    University of Oklahoma (Saeed Salehi)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Real-Time Drilling Optimization System for Improved Overall Rate of Penetration and Reduced Cost/Ft in Geothermal Drilling

    Oklahoma State University (Mohammed F. Al Dushaishi)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    10:50 / 1:50

    Downhole Sensing and Event-Driven Sensor Fusion for Depth-of-Cut Based Autonomous Fault Response and Drilling Optimization

    SNL (Jiann Su)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Rotary Piston Motor for High-Temperature Directional Drilling

    SNL (David Raymond)

    Subsurface Accessibility

    12:40 / 3:40

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    EDT

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 2

    GTO (Jeff Winick)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    Geothermal Non-Technical Barriers: A State and Local Perspective

    NREL (Aaron Levine)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    8:50 / 11:50

    GT-Mod

    SNL (Tom Lowry)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    U.S. DOE Geothermal Data Repository (GDR)

    NREL (Jon Weers)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    10:50 / 1:50

    Geothermal Resource Portfolio Optimization & Reporting Technique

    NREL (Aaron Levine)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    Geothermal Student Competition

    NREL (Caity Smith)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    12:40 / 3:40

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    1:40 / 3:40

    Development of Ionic Based Fluid To Improve Fluid Hydraulics in Enhanced Geothermal Systems

    Oklahoma State University (Mohammed F. Al Dushaishi)

Day 6: Thursday, May 26, 2022

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 1

    GTO (Elisabet Metcalfe)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    GETEM

    NREL (Chad Augustine)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    8:50 / 11:50

    Closed Loop Geothermal Working Group - PNNL

    PNNL (Mark White)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Closed Loop Geothermal Working Group - INL

    INL (Theron Marshall)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    10:50 /1:50

    Closed Loop Geothermal Working Group - SNL

    SNL (Mario Martinez)

    Data, Modeling, and Analysis

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    11:50 / 2:50

    TBD

    TBD

    TBD

    12:35 / 3:35

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    (PDT / EDT)

    Title

    Presenter

    Topic Area

    7:50 / 10:50

    Welcome Greeting Virtual Room 2

    GTO (TBD)

     

    8:00 / 11:00

    WS: Pressure, Orientation & Timing (POT) for Anhydrous Energetic Stimulation

    SNL (Eric Robey)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    8:50 / 11:50

    WS: CO2-Responsive Fracturing Fluids for Enhanced Geothermal Systems

    PNNL (Carlos Fernandez)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    9:35 / 12:35

    Break

     

     

    10:00 / 1:00

    Foam Fracturing Study for Stimulation Development of Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS)

    ORNL (Hong Wang)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    10:50 / 1:50

    Fully Retrievable, High Temperature Packer System Utilizing Thermally Degradable Expanding Foam for Zonal Isolation

    HotRock Research Organization (Geoffrey Garrison)

    Subsurface Enhancement and Sustainability

    11:35 / 2:35

    Break

     

     

    12:40 / 3:40

    Return to Main Room

     

     

  • Start
    EDT

    Title

    Presenter

    12:40 / 3:40

    Thermally Induced Calcium Carbonate Precipitation (TICP) As a Method To Control Hydraulic Properties in Enhanced Geothermal Systems

    Montana State University (Lee H Spangler)

    12:55 / 3:55

    Reversible Reservoir Permeability Modification via In-situ Formation of Silicate Gel Plugs from Micro/Nano-Encapsulated Reactant Fluids

    LBNL (Seiji Nakagawa)

    1:10 / 4:10

    Innovative Particle Gels for Controlling Preferential Fluid Flow in Geothermal Reservoirs to Enhance Heat Recovery

    Missouri University of Science and Technology (Baojun Bai)

    1:25 / 4:25

    Temperature-Sensitive Hydraulic Conductivity Controller Proppant for Enhanced Geothermal Systems

    Penn State University Park (Arash Taleghani)

    1:40 / 4:40

    Temperature-responsive Swelling Particles for Elimination of Cooled Short Circuits in a Discrete Fracture

    Cornell University (Adam Hawkins)